Pixel2Tech

How to Compare Digital Marketing Agency Proposals Before You Hire

Got several digital marketing agency proposals? Put scope, people, fees, ad spend, ownership and exit terms in one table before you choose.

  • Written by
  • Topic: Marketing
  • Published
  • 8 min read
Business owner comparing printed marketing agency proposals side by side on a desk

Key takeaways

  • Send every agency the same written brief, with one goal, one budget and one start date, so each digital marketing agency proposal answers the same question.
  • Copy every proposal into one table with the same rows for scope, people, fees, ad spend, accounts, reporting, data protection and contract terms.
  • Ask for the agency fee and the ad spend as separate amounts, in the same currency and on the same tax basis.
  • Score each row on what the proposal and the follow-up call actually say, and treat a blank row as a question to send back.
  • Choose the agency with a clear plan for the first three months and a contract that lets you leave with your accounts, data and files.

Why a digital marketing agency proposal is hard to compare

Ask three agencies for help and you will get three documents that look nothing alike. One is a two-page letter, one is a slide deck and one is a price list with a link to book a call. Each digital marketing agency proposal uses its own words for the same work, groups services in its own way and leaves out different things. That makes the headline fees hard to put side by side.

This guide is for owners and marketing leads at small and midsize businesses in the United States, the United Kingdom and the European Union who have proposals on the desk, or are about to ask for them. It shows how to copy different proposals into one comparison table, what to ask when a row is blank and how to pick the agency whose plan you can check after you sign.

If you already work with an agency and are deciding whether to leave, start with 10 Signs It's Time to Replace Your Digital Marketing Agency. This article picks up at the next step, when new proposals are in front of you.

Send every agency the same brief

You can only compare proposals that answer the same question. Before you contact anyone, write a one-page brief and send the same version to every agency. An agency that hears 'we want more sales' has to guess. An agency that hears 'we want more booked consultations from buyers in Germany and the Netherlands' can plan the channels, the content and the budget.

Put these points in the brief:

  • One main goal for the next six months, such as more booked calls or more online orders in a named market
  • The customers you want to reach and the countries or regions where they live
  • A monthly budget for the agency fee, and a separate budget for ad spend if you plan to run ads
  • The channels you use today and who runs them
  • The accounts you already own, such as your website, ad accounts, analytics and email platform
  • Your start date, your decision date and the name of the person who will decide

Keep the process fair

Give every agency the same deadline and offer each one the same short call for questions. If you answer a question for one agency, send the answer to all of them. The proposals stay comparable, and you learn which agencies ask useful questions before they quote.

Build one table to compare digital marketing agencies

Copy each proposal into the same rows. Agencies describe the same work in different ways, so write down what each one actually commits to, in your own words. Leave a cell blank when the proposal does not say. The blank cells become your follow-up questions.

Rows to fill in for every proposal
RowWhat to write downQuestion to send if it is missing
ScopeServices, channels and the number of posts, ads, emails or articles each monthWhat exactly will you deliver each month?
PeopleNamed roles, who leads the account and the hours each role getsWho works on our account each week?
Agency feeThe monthly fee, any setup fee and anything billed separatelyWhich costs sit outside this fee?
Ad spendThe budget that goes to the ad platforms, kept apart from the feeHow much of the total reaches the platforms?
Currency and taxThe currency, whether the figure includes VAT or sales tax and how often you payIs this figure before or after tax?
AccountsWhich accounts the agency will create, and in whose nameWill we be the owner or admin of every account?
ReportingThe business numbers in the monthly report and the date it arrivesCan we see a sample report?
Data protectionHow the agency stores customer data and handles consentWill you sign a data processing agreement?
ContractMinimum term, notice period, price changes and exit termsWhat happens to our files and accounts if we leave?
First three monthsThe work planned for each month of the first phaseWhat will be live by the end of month one?

Convert every proposal to the same scope

Proposals rarely price the same work. One agency may quote eight social posts a month with ad management included. Another may quote twelve posts and charge for ads on top. Before you compare cost, pick one scope that fits your brief and ask each agency to price it. Then the fees describe the same work.

Read the assumptions

A careful proposal lists what the agency expects from you, such as product photos, approvals within two working days or access to your customer list. Those assumptions change the real cost of the work, because your team has to supply them. If a proposal has no list of assumptions, ask for one.

Separate the fee, the ad spend and the tax

The agency fee pays for planning, creative and management. The ad spend goes to Google, Meta, LinkedIn or another platform. When a proposal merges the two into one figure, you cannot tell how much of your money reached the platforms. Ask for both amounts in writing.

Then check how the ad spend gets paid. The safest setup for you is an ad account in your business name, with your own payment method on file and the agency added as a user. Some agencies run client ads through their own accounts and bill the spend back with a markup. Ask whether a markup applies and how much it is.

If the agencies you compare work in different countries, put every figure in the same currency and on the same tax basis. A UK agency may quote in pounds with VAT added. An agency in Ireland or Spain may quote in euros. A US agency may quote in dollars, and sales tax rules for services vary by state. Ask each agency whether its figure includes tax and how often it bills, and ask your accountant how VAT applies when the agency sits in another country.

Check who owns the accounts and the work

A proposal should say which accounts the agency will use and who owns them. Every account should belong to your business, with the agency added as a user or partner. If an agency builds your ads, audiences or email lists inside its own accounts, you can lose that history when the contract ends, and the next team starts from nothing.

Look for these in each proposal, and ask about any that are missing:

  • Google Ads, Meta and LinkedIn ad accounts in your business name and billed to you
  • Google Analytics, Google Tag Manager and Google Search Console with you as the owner
  • Your email platform and subscriber list under your own login
  • Your Google Business Profile, with you as the primary owner
  • Your website, domain and hosting logins
  • Creative files, videos and copy saved in a folder you control, with the right to keep using them after the contract ends

Compare the reporting and tracking plans

A monthly report should show whether the work brought in business. Reach, impressions and likes show activity, but they do not tell you whether anyone called. Ask each agency which business numbers it will report, such as enquiries, booked calls, form fills, orders or revenue, and how it will tie each number to a channel.

That only works if someone sets up tracking before the campaigns start. Check whether each proposal includes conversion tracking on your website, a link to your CRM or booking tool and an agreed definition of a lead. If many customers contact you by phone, ask how the agency will count those calls.

Consent rules also shape what a report can show. In the UK and EU, analytics and advertising cookies need the visitor's consent, so visitors who decline will not appear in some of your numbers. A good proposal explains how the agency will set up consent and what that means for the report. Ask each agency for a sample report with client details removed, and check that it explains what changed and what the team will do next month. For a model of a report that ties the work to results, see A Client Reporting Dashboard That Proves Your Work Every Month.

Check the data protection and email rules

Most digital marketing services touch customer data. Email campaigns use your subscriber list, ad audiences can use customer uploads and lead forms collect names and contact details. Each proposal should say how the agency will handle that data.

In the UK and EU, the GDPR requires a written contract when another company processes personal data on your behalf. Agencies usually call this a data processing agreement. Ask whether each agency will sign one and where it will store your data. Marketing email to individuals in the UK and EU generally needs their prior consent, so the agency should ask how you collected your list before it sends anything.

In the US, the CAN-SPAM Act sets rules for commercial email, including a working unsubscribe link and your postal address in every message. An agency that sends email for you should know the rules for every country on your list and should explain how it will follow them.

Score the proposals and test the top two

Once the table is full, give each row a score of 0, 1 or 2. A 2 means the proposal answers the row clearly and the follow-up call backed it up. A 1 means part of the answer is there. A 0 means the row is blank or the answer worries you. Before you start, decide which rows matter most to your business and count those twice.

Scores narrow the field, but you still make the decision. Invite the top two agencies to a second call and ask each one to walk you through its first three months. Use the same questions with both:

  • Who will join our regular calls, and which time zone do they work in?
  • What will be live at the end of the first month?
  • Which numbers will tell us the plan is working by the end of the first phase?
  • Can we speak to a current client in a similar industry?
  • What would you change in your proposal now that you know more about us?

Listen for specific answers

A strong agency asks about your margins, your sales cycle and your busy seasons. It tells you which parts of the goal it can affect and which depend on your own team. An agency that answers every question with the same pitch is unlikely to learn your business after you sign.

Red flags that rule out a proposal

One weak row is a reason to ask more questions. The signs below are reasons to drop the proposal, because they make the rest of the table hard to trust.

  • A guaranteed ranking position on Google or a guaranteed number of leads
  • Ad spend and agency fee merged into one figure with no breakdown
  • A refusal to set up ad and analytics accounts in your business name
  • No named people, only the agency's name and logo
  • A long minimum term with no notice period and no clause on returning your files
  • A proposal that never mentions your goal, your market or anything else from your brief

Start with a first phase and a review date

Rather than a twelve-month commitment, ask the agency you choose for a first phase of about three months. Write down the work it will deliver, the numbers you will review and the date of the review. At the review, keep what worked, drop what did not and agree on the next phase together.

Pixel2Tech is a branding, web design, video and automation studio that works with businesses worldwide, including clients in the United States, United Kingdom and European Union. We offer SEO and search growth, social media and email and campaign strategy services. You can see how we structure our work on the pricing page, or contact us with your brief if you would like a second opinion on the proposals you have.

Sources and further reading

Frequently asked questions

What should a digital marketing agency proposal include?

It should name the services and channels, the monthly deliverables, the people who will do the work and how much of their time you get. It should list the agency fee and the ad spend separately, say which accounts you will own, describe the monthly report and set out the contract length, notice period and exit terms. Treat anything missing as a question to ask before you compare.

How many agencies should I compare?

Three is a workable number for most small and midsize businesses. Fewer gives you little to compare, and more takes time you could spend checking references. Send the same brief to each one, give them the same deadline and hold a short call with each before you score the proposals. If none of the three fits, revise the brief before you widen the search.

Why do agency proposals for the same brief look so different?

Agencies make different assumptions about scope, channels and the work your own team will do. One may include ad creative and another may expect you to supply it. One may quote a monthly fee and another a fee per campaign. Ask each agency to list its assumptions, then convert every proposal into the same monthly scope before you compare cost.

Should I choose the cheapest digital marketing services proposal?

Only if it covers the same work as the others. A lower fee can mean fewer deliverables, a more junior team, ad spend left out or setup work billed later. Price the same scope across every proposal first. Then compare what is left, such as the people, the reporting and the exit terms, because those decide how the work runs after you sign.

What contract terms should I check before I sign with a marketing agency?

Check the minimum term, the notice period and what happens to your accounts, files and data when you leave. Find out who owns the creative the agency produces, how it handles customer data and whether the fee can change during the term. In the UK and EU, ask for a data processing agreement if the agency will handle personal data such as your email list.

About the author: Asad Farooq

Co-Founder & COO

Pixel2Tech is a Lahore studio for brand, web, video and automation work. We write about problems we see in client projects.

More about Asad

Get a second opinion on your marketing proposals

A good digital marketing agency proposal names the work, the people, the accounts you will own and the numbers you will see each month. If you would like Pixel2Tech to review the proposals you have, or to write one against the same brief, book a call and send us the brief you shared with the other agencies.

Send a project brief

Related Pixel2Tech services

Get new articles by email

Leave your email and we'll send new posts when they're published.

WhatsApp us