How to Choose an SEO Agency: Questions to Ask Before You Sign
The questions to ask an SEO agency before you sign, what a proposal should contain, who should own your accounts and whether to hire local or remote.
- Written by Asad Farooq
- Topic: SEO
- Published
- 8 min read

Key takeaways
- Write down what you want from search before you speak to any SEO agency, so you can judge every proposal against the same goal.
- Ask every agency who will do the work, what the first month contains and how it earns links, and get the answers in writing.
- A proposal should list monthly deliverables, priority pages, a contract term, an exit clause and a sample report.
- Create Search Console, Analytics, your Google Business Profile and your website logins in your own name, and give the agency user access.
- Local and remote agencies can both do good work, so judge each one on experience in your market, overlap in working hours, contract terms and past work you can verify.
In this article (12 sections)
Start with what you need from an SEO agency
Search for an SEO agency and you will find a long list of firms that make the same promises on their websites. Working out how to choose an SEO agency gets easier when you stop comparing promises. Ask every agency the same questions, then compare the written answers.
Before you call anyone, write down what you want search to do for your business. A dental practice in Chicago wants patients from nearby neighborhoods who search for a treatment. A manufacturer in the English Midlands may want trade buyers who search in English from other countries. An online store in the Netherlands may want its product pages to show in several EU markets and languages. Each goal needs different work, and a good agency will ask you about it in the first conversation.
Also write down where you are now. Is Google Search Console set up? Do you know which pages bring enquiries? Have you worked with an agency before, and what went wrong? These notes give every agency the same starting point and make the proposals easier to compare.
Questions to ask an SEO agency on the first call
Ask each agency the same questions, take notes and ask for the important answers in writing afterwards. How specific each answer is matters more than how confident it sounds.
Google's own guide for people hiring an SEO suggests similar questions. It recommends asking for examples of previous work, whether the SEO follows Google Search Essentials, what results to expect and in what timeframe, how they measure success, what experience they have in your industry and your country, and whether they will share all the changes they make to your site. The questions below add detail to that list:
- Who will work on my account, and what does each person do? You want names and roles, not 'our team'.
- What will you do in the first month? A good answer mentions an audit, access set up, keyword research and the first fixes.
- Which problems can you already see on my site? An agency that looked before the call can name two or three.
- How do you choose keywords, and how do you match them to pages?
- How will you earn links? Listen for relevant industry sites, trade bodies or local press. Walk away from fixed monthly link counts or paid placements.
- Will you make changes on the site yourselves, or will my developer make them?
- What does the monthly report show, and can I see a sample with client details removed?
- What happens to my accounts, content and data if I leave?
- Can I speak to a current client?
Questions a good agency will ask you
The first call should run both ways. An agency that plans to do useful work needs to understand your business, so it will ask you questions too. Notice which agencies ask them and which ones move straight to their packages.
Expect questions such as these:
- Which services or products bring you the most profit, and which ones do you want more of?
- Which cities, regions or countries do you serve, and in which languages?
- Who are your customers, and what do they ask before they buy?
- Which competitors do you lose work to?
- What SEO work has the site had before, and who did it?
- Who on your team can approve content and answer questions about your services?
- Who builds and maintains your website, and how do changes get made?
Choosing between a local and a remote SEO agency
An SEO agency does not need to sit in your office. The work happens in Search Console, your website admin and shared documents, so a team in another city or another country can do it. Location still affects a few practical things, so check each one in the table below before you decide.
Google's guide for people hiring an SEO suggests asking about experience in your country or city, and about international sites if you sell abroad. That experience tells you more than the agency's address. A remote agency that has worked on sites in your market can serve you well, and a local agency with no experience in your industry may not.
Pixel2Tech is a studio based in Lahore, Pakistan that works with clients in the US, UK, Canada and the EU, so every question in this section applies to us too.
| Topic | Why it matters | What to ask |
|---|---|---|
| Market knowledge | Search habits, spelling and directories differ between the US, the UK and each EU country | Which sites have you worked on in my country, and in which languages? |
| Working hours | Questions and urgent fixes wait when your hours never overlap | Which hours do you work in my time zone, and how fast do you reply? |
| Meetings | Some owners prefer to meet the team in person | Can we meet in person, or will every meeting happen on video? |
| Contract | The contract may fall under another country's law | Which country's law governs the contract, and how do we settle disputes? |
| Invoicing | Currency, tax and transfer fees change what you pay | Which currency do you invoice in, and does the fee include VAT or sales tax? |
| Personal data | UK and EU businesses have legal duties when they share personal data | How do you handle personal data, and will you sign a data processing agreement? |
What to ask for in a proposal
A proposal is the document you will hold the agency to, so it needs more than a list of services. Ask for each item below before you sign. If an agency resists putting something in writing, that tells you how the work will go.
| Item | What it should say |
|---|---|
| Goal | The business goal you agreed, in your words, such as more enquiries for two services |
| First phase | What the audit covers, when you receive it and which fixes follow |
| Monthly deliverables | Pages improved, content pieces, technical checks and local SEO tasks, with quantities |
| Priority pages | The pages the agency will start with, and why |
| People | Who does the work, and who your main contact is |
| Link building method | Where links will come from, with no paid placements |
| Reporting | What the report contains, how often it arrives and whether a call follows |
| Access | Which accounts the agency needs, created in your name |
| Term and exit | Minimum term, notice period and what you keep when you leave |
Keep ownership of every account
Many business owners only find out who owns their accounts when they try to leave an agency. By then the agency may hold the Google Business Profile, the Search Console property or even the domain. Getting them back can take weeks, and some businesses start again with a new profile and lose their reviews.
Set the rule before work starts. You create and own each account with a business email you control, and the agency gets user or manager access. That covers Google Search Console, Google Analytics, your Google Business Profile, your domain registrar, your hosting account and the admin login for your website. Content the agency writes for you should belong to you once you pay for it, and the contract should say so.
While you are still comparing agencies, share only what each one needs to assess your site. Google's guide suggests giving a prospective SEO read access to Search Console at this stage, without write access. Our website ownership checklist lists what else to confirm.
Agree how changes get made on your site
SEO work means changing your website. The agency rewrites titles, merges pages, adds redirects and publishes new content. Before the agency starts, agree who makes each kind of change and how you approve it.
If the agency will edit the site itself, give it a separate login with its own name, so every change shows who made it. If your developer makes the changes, ask the agency to send fixes in a clear list with the page address, the problem and the exact change needed. Decide whether content goes live straight away or waits for your approval, and who on your side gives that approval. If the agency does not write content and you need service pages written, see our copywriting service.
Ask the agency to keep a change log, a simple list of what it changed, on which page and on what date. Google's guide also suggests asking whether an SEO will share all the changes it makes to your site. When traffic moves up or down, the log lets you match the movement to a change instead of guessing.
Reporting you should expect
A monthly report should answer three questions. What work did the agency do? What changed in search? What happens next month?
The work section should match the deliverables in the proposal, with links to the pages changed and the content published. The search section should show clicks and impressions from Google Search Console for your priority pages and searches, compared with the previous month and the same month last year where you have the data. The business section should show enquiries, calls or sales that came from search, so set up your forms and call tracking before the work starts.
Ask whether a call comes with the report. A short monthly call lets you ask questions and keeps the agency accountable for the plan. Our post on a client reporting dashboard that proves the work describes what a clear monthly view looks like.
Check past work you can verify
Every agency has case studies. The useful ones name a client, a site and a time period you can check. Ask for live pages the agency improved and read them. Ask to speak to a current client, and ask that client what the agency delivered each month and how it handled problems.
Look at the agency's own website as well. Check whether its service pages are clear, whether its blog has useful articles and whether its contact details match across the site. An agency that cannot keep its own site in order will struggle with yours.
If the agency is local, visit the office and meet the people who will do the work. If it is remote, ask for a video call with the people who will work on your account, not only the salesperson.
Red flags that should end the conversation
Stop talking to any SEO agency that does any of the following:
- Promises a first page ranking or a set position by a date. Google's guide says no one can guarantee a number one ranking on Google.
- Sells a fixed number of backlinks per month. Google's spam policies list buying or selling links for ranking purposes as link spam.
- Talks about link popularity schemes or submitting your site to thousands of search engines, which Google's guide tells you to avoid.
- Opens with a cold email that promises rankings. Google's guide tells site owners to be wary of SEO firms that email them out of the blue.
- Refuses to explain its methods, or calls them secret.
- Wants to own your Google Business Profile, Search Console or domain.
- Offers fake reviews or review swaps.
- Cannot tell you who will do the work.
- Sends a proposal with no deliverables, only a fee and a list of service names.
How to choose an SEO agency from your shortlist
Once you have two or three proposals, put them in one table with the same rows for goal, first phase, monthly deliverables, people, links, reporting, access and exit. The agency that fills in every row with specific answers is usually the safer choice, even if another one sounded more confident on the call.
If you are still unsure, ask your preferred agency for a defined first phase before a monthly agreement. That phase could cover an audit, keyword mapping and the first round of fixes, with a fixed fee and a delivery date. At the end you will have documents you own and a clear view of how the agency works, and you can decide on the monthly contract with evidence in front of you.
If you are replacing an agency that did not deliver, read 10 signs it's time to replace your digital marketing agency to make sure the new contract fixes the old problems. You can also read how we approach SEO and search growth, see our pricing or contact us with your website and goals.
Sources and further reading
Frequently asked questions
How do I choose an SEO agency?
Start with your goal and your current position, before you speak to anyone. Write down which services you want more enquiries for, which areas or countries you serve and what SEO work the site has had before. Check that Google Search Console is set up. These notes give every agency the same brief and make their proposals easier to compare.
What questions should I ask an SEO agency on the first call?
Ask who will work on your account, what the first month contains, how they choose keywords, how they earn links, what the monthly report shows and what happens to your accounts if you leave. Ask them to name two or three problems they can already see on your site. Specific answers show the agency looked at your business before the call.
Should I hire a local SEO agency or a remote one?
Either can work. A local agency makes meetings in person easier and may already know your market. A remote agency can do the same work over video calls and shared documents. Judge both on the same evidence, which means experience in your country, a written scope, past work you can verify, accounts in your name and enough overlap in working hours to answer questions within a day.
Should I sign a long SEO contract?
Only if it has a clear exit clause and monthly deliverables you can check. SEO takes months to show results, so a one month trial rarely proves much, but a long contract with no notice period traps you if the work stops. A safer route is a defined first phase, such as an audit and fixes, then a monthly agreement with a notice period.
How do I check an SEO agency's past results?
Ask for examples you can check yourself, such as live pages the agency improved, a current client you can call or Search Console screenshots shared with the client's permission. Visit those sites and read the pages. Treat claims you cannot check with caution, such as large traffic increases with no named site, no dates and no source.
About the author: Asad Farooq
Co-Founder & COO
Pixel2Tech is a Lahore studio for brand, web, video and automation work. We write about problems we see in client projects.
More about AsadPut these questions to our SEO team
The questions in this guide apply to us as much as to any other agency. If you are comparing SEO agencies, put every one of them to our SEO and search growth team, ask for the answers in writing and compare them with the other proposals on your list.
Related articles
Business ·
10 Signs It's Time to Replace Your Digital Marketing Agency
Is your marketing agency failing to deliver results? Here are the warning signs, the hidden costs, and what a real digital growth partner looks like.

Custom Platforms ·
A Client Reporting Dashboard That Proves Your Work Every Month
A client reporting dashboard shows results, not activity. Here is what to include so clients see the value of your work every month.

Web Development ·
Do You Own Your Website? Domain, Hosting & Code Checklist
Audit who controls your domain, hosting, email, platform accounts, analytics and code rights, then use a handover checklist before the final payment.

SEO ·
What an SEO Content Agency Should Deliver Every Month
The monthly work an SEO content agency should deliver: keyword mapping, briefs, editing, internal links, content refreshes and a clear report.
Related Pixel2Tech services
Get new articles by email
Leave your email and we'll send new posts when they're published.