Pixel2Tech

Marketing Agency, Advertising Agency, or a Marketing and Advertising Agency?

What a marketing agency does, what an advertising agency does, when a combined agency makes sense and the questions to ask before you hire either.

  • Written by
  • Topic: Marketing
  • Published
  • 7 min read
Agency team planning a campaign around a table covered with layouts and notes

Key takeaways

  • A marketing agency decides who to reach and runs the ongoing channels, while an advertising agency creates paid ads and places them.
  • Choose a marketing agency when the audience, message or website is the problem, because better ads will not fix those gaps.
  • Choose an advertising agency when your plan and offer already work and paid media is the main way you grow.
  • A combined marketing and advertising agency suits businesses that want one plan, one report and one team across paid and organic channels.
  • Ask every agency who does the work, how it measures success and whether your accounts stay in your name.

Two kinds of agency with overlapping names

Search for help with growth and you will find marketing agencies, advertising agencies, digital agencies, creative agencies and firms that call themselves a marketing and advertising agency. The labels overlap, and many agencies use them loosely. That makes it hard to know what you are buying, and easy to hire a team that is good at a job you do not need done.

Here is the short version. A marketing agency helps you decide who to reach, what to say and which channels to use, then runs the ongoing work across those channels. An advertising agency makes paid ads and places them in front of people. The first works on the whole route a customer takes before buying. The second works on one part of that route, the paid message.

This guide explains both types, shows where they overlap and helps you decide which one your business needs now. It ends with the questions to ask any agency before you sign, whatever it calls itself.

What a marketing agency does

A marketing agency plans and runs the activities that bring customers to a business and help them decide to buy, across paid and unpaid channels.

Marketing starts before any ad exists. A marketing agency looks at who your customers are, why they choose you, what your competitors say and where your buyers spend their time online. It turns that research into a plan that names the channels, the messages and the numbers you will track.

The ongoing work depends on the plan. It often includes some of the following.

  • Search engine optimisation for your website and Google Business Profile
  • Social media content and community management
  • Email newsletters and automated follow-up
  • Blog posts, guides and service page copy
  • Website changes that turn more visitors into enquiries
  • Tracking and reporting across every channel

How a marketing agency measures success

Some marketing agencies also run paid ads, usually as one channel inside the wider plan. Either way, a marketing agency judges its work on business results over months, such as more enquiries, more sales or a lower cost to win each customer. Expect a monthly report that connects the activity in each channel to those results.

What an advertising agency does

An advertising agency creates paid messages and buys the space to show them, on platforms such as Meta, Google, TikTok, YouTube, television, radio, print or outdoor screens.

Advertising is a narrower job, done in depth. An advertising agency turns your message into a campaign idea, then produces the ads. That can mean video ads, static images, carousels, scripts, headlines and the copy around them. It then plans where the ads will run, splits the budget between placements and manages the campaigns once they go live.

Traditional advertising agencies started out making ads for television, radio, newspapers and billboards, and many still buy that media for large brands. Digital advertising agencies work mainly on online platforms, where the creative and the targeting can change every week. In both cases the focus is the ad and the people who see it. An advertising agency judges its work on campaign numbers, such as reach, clicks, cost per result and return on ad spend.

Creative quality decides most of the outcome here. Test ad ideas against each other before you raise the spend, as described in Ad Creative Testing for Small Budgets.

Marketing agency vs advertising agency side by side

The table below sets the two types next to each other. Real agencies often sit somewhere in between, so use it to read a proposal, not to sort agencies into boxes.

How the two agency types differ
QuestionMarketing agencyAdvertising agency
Main jobDecide who to reach and how, then run the channelsCreate paid ads and place them
Typical workSEO, content, social media, email, website conversion, reportingCampaign ideas, ad creative, copy, media planning and buying, campaign management
Time frameOngoing, often on a monthly retainerOften built around campaigns and launches, though some work on retainer
Main measureEnquiries, sales and the cost to win a customerReach, clicks, cost per result and return on ad spend
Best whenYou need a plan and steady work across channelsYou have a clear plan and need ads that perform

How to tell which type an agency really is

The name on the website tells you little. Plenty of firms call themselves a full service agency and do most of their work in one area. Three checks show you what an agency actually does well, whatever its label says.

First, look at the portfolio. An agency that shows mostly ad designs, video spots and campaign launches works like an advertising agency. An agency that shows website changes, content plans, search rankings and email flows works like a marketing agency. If the case studies only show pictures and no results, ask what changed for each client.

Second, ask who is on the team. A marketing agency will have strategists, writers and people who handle SEO, email and analytics. An advertising agency will have creative directors, designers, video editors, copywriters and media buyers. A combined agency should have people in both groups, and it should be willing to name them.

Third, ask for a sample report. A marketing report talks about enquiries, sales and where they came from. An advertising report talks about campaigns, creative and the cost of each result. The report shows you what the agency thinks its job is, and that is the job it will do for you.

When your business needs a marketing agency

Choose a marketing agency when the problem is bigger than the ads. These are the common signs.

  • You are not sure who your best customers are or why they buy
  • Your website gets visitors but few enquiries
  • You post on social media without a plan and cannot tell what works
  • You rely on referrals or a single ad platform and want more sources of leads
  • Nobody in the business owns marketing each week

Why ads alone will not close these gaps

An ad sends people somewhere. If the message is unclear, or the page they land on does not answer their questions, more ad spend sends more people to the same problem. In these cases you need someone to set the direction first and then do the steady work that keeps leads coming in.

When your business needs an advertising agency

Choose an advertising agency when your strategy is clear and paid media is the main way you grow. These are the signs to look for.

  • You know your audience, offer and message, and they already bring in customers
  • You have an in-house marketer or team who owns the plan
  • Your ads look tired and results fall as the same creative repeats
  • You are launching a product or campaign and need a batch of new creative
  • You spend enough on ads that better creative and buying will change the result

Give an advertising agency a clear brief

An advertising agency does its best work with your audience, your offer, your past results and the landing pages the ads will send people to. Ads that promise one thing and land on a page that says another lose money, so review the page as well as the ad. Our guide to Google Ads landing pages for service businesses explains how to match the two.

When a combined marketing and advertising agency makes sense

Many small and mid-sized businesses do not want to manage two agencies, a separate designer and a freelancer for email. A combined marketing and advertising agency does the planning and the paid campaigns in one team. That helps most when the business is too small for a full in-house marketing department. The main advantages are these.

  • One plan covers ads, social media, email and the website, so the message stays the same everywhere
  • The people who write the ads also see the sales data, so they learn sooner which messages work
  • You get one report and one person to call
  • The team can reuse creative made for ads in organic social media and email

The risk with a combined agency

The risk is a team that does everything at an average level. Check that a combined agency has named people for strategy, ad creative and campaign management, and ask to see current work in each area. Ask how it decides how much budget goes to paid ads and how much goes to SEO or email. A good answer starts with your goals and your numbers. A weak answer starts with whatever service the agency sells most.

Questions to ask before you hire either type

Use the same questions with every agency, whatever it calls itself. The answers show what the team actually does day to day.

  • What will you deliver in the first month, and what do you need from us?
  • Who will plan the work, who will make the creative and who will manage the campaigns?
  • How do you measure success, and which numbers will we see each month?
  • Will our ads, pages and analytics run in accounts we own?
  • How do you split the budget between channels, and when do you change the split?
  • How do you charge for strategy, for creative and for managing ad spend?
  • Can you show a current client in a similar industry and explain what you did?

If you already have an agency

Put the same questions to your current agency. If the answers worry you, our list of 10 Signs It's Time to Replace Your Digital Marketing Agency can help you decide whether to fix the arrangement or move on.

Where Pixel2Tech fits

Pixel2Tech is a branding, web design, video and automation studio based in Lahore, Pakistan, working with businesses worldwide. We work as one team across planning and creative. Our campaign strategy service sets the audience, offer, channels and calendar. Our ad creative design and video editing and ads teams make the static, carousel and video ads. Our social media and email team runs those channels between campaigns.

If you are not sure which kind of help you need, contact us and we will help you work out whether the gap is in the plan, the ads or both.

Frequently asked questions

What is a marketing and advertising agency?

It is an agency that does both jobs. It plans your marketing, including the audience, the message and the channels, and it also makes and runs paid ads. The benefit is one team and one plan across ads, social media, email and your website. Before you hire one, check that it has named people for strategy, creative and campaign management.

What is the main difference between a marketing agency and an advertising agency?

A marketing agency decides who to reach, what to say and which channels to use, then runs the ongoing work across those channels. An advertising agency focuses on paid messages. It creates ads and places them on platforms such as Meta, Google, TikTok, television or outdoor screens. Marketing covers the whole route to a sale. Advertising covers the paid part of it.

Is a digital marketing agency the same as an advertising agency?

Not quite. A digital marketing agency works across online channels, which can include SEO, content, social media, email and paid ads. A digital advertising agency concentrates on paid online ads and the creative behind them. Many agencies offer some of both, so read the proposal rather than the label, and ask which services the agency delivers with its own team.

Should a small business hire a marketing agency or an advertising agency first?

Start with a marketing agency, or a combined one, if your audience, offer or message is not yet clear, because ads cannot fix those gaps. If you already know who buys from you and why, and your website turns visitors into enquiries, an advertising agency can help you reach more of those buyers. Start with the problem you have, then pick the agency type.

How do marketing and advertising agencies charge?

Models vary between agencies. Marketing agencies often work on a monthly retainer for ongoing work. Advertising agencies may charge per campaign, per piece of creative, a monthly management fee or a share of the ad spend. Ask each agency to show its fee and your ad spend as separate figures, and to explain in writing what each part of the fee pays for.

About the author: Asad Farooq

Co-Founder & COO

Pixel2Tech is a Lahore studio for brand, web, video and automation work. We write about problems we see in client projects.

More about Asad

Not sure whether you need a plan, ads or both?

The right agency depends on the problem you have. If your audience and message are unclear, start with a plan. If the plan works and the ads look tired, start with creative. Pixel2Tech plans campaigns, designs ad creative, edits video ads and runs social media and email, so we can look at where you are and tell you which part to fix first.

Send a project brief

Related Pixel2Tech services

Get new articles by email

Leave your email and we'll send new posts when they're published.

WhatsApp us